All the Real Girls

Paul Schneider

Paul

Zooey Deschanel

Noel

Shea Whigham

Tip

Danny McBride

Bust-Ass (as Danny R. McBride)

Maurice Compte

Bo

Heather McComb

Mary-Margaret

Benjamin Mouton

Uncle Leland

John Kirkland

Justin

James Marshall Case

Judge Harvey

Patricia Clarkson

Elvira

Maya Ling Pruitt

Feng-Shui

Eddie Rouse

Dancing Orderly

Karey Williams

Tammy Clinard

Matt Chapman

Strong Bad

Maribeth Ayers

Noel's Friend

Summer Shelton

Noel's other friend