Big Fan

Patton Oswalt

Paul Aufiero

Kevin Corrigan

Sal

Michael Rapaport

Philadelphia Phil

Marcia Jean Kurtz

Paul's Mom

Serafina Fiore

Gina Aufiero

Gino Cafarelli

Jeff Aufiero

Jonathan Hamm

Quantrell Bishop

Matt Servitto

Detective Velardi

Joe Garden

Dennis

Polly Humphreys

Christine

Scott Ferrall

Sports Dogg

Sidné Anderson

Hospital Doctor

Julian Lane

Birthday Boy

Caroline Gallo

Gina and Jeff Daughter

Maya Louise Dispenza

Christine and Dennis Daughter

Cookie Bradshaw

Law-Office Ad Woman