Handsome Harry

Jamey Sheridan

Harry Sweeney

Steve Buscemi

Thomas Kelley

Mariann Mayberry

Judy Rheems

Aidan Quinn

Prof. Porter

John Savage

Peter Rheems

Campbell Scott

David Kagan

Titus Welliver

Gebhardt

Karen Young

Muriel

Jayne Atkinson

Kelley's Wife

Bill Sage

Pauley

Emily Donahoe

Kelley's Daughter

Asher Grodman

Bobby Sweeney

Andrew Dolan

Sam

Rutanya Alda

Mrs. Schroeder

Derrick Jones

Bat Patron (uncredited)