Black Bart

Yvonne De Carlo

Lola Montez

Dan Duryea

Charles E. Boles / Black Bart

Jeffrey Lynn

Lance Hardeen

Percy Kilbride

Jersey Brady

Lloyd Gough

Sheriff Gordon

Frank Lovejoy

Mark Lorimer

John McIntire

Clark

Don Beddoe

J.T. Hall

Ray Walker

MacFarland

Soledad Jiménez

Teresa

Eddy Waller

Ed Mason

Anne O'Neal

Mrs. Harmon

Chief Many Treaties

Indian

Eddie Acuff

Elkins (uncredited)

Ray Bennett

Henry (uncredited)

Russ Conway

Wells Fargo Agent Clayton (uncredited)