The Hangman

Robert Taylor

Mackenzie Bovard

Tina Louise

Selah Jennison

Fess Parker

Sheriff Buck Weston

Jack Lord

Johnny Bishop

Gene Evans

"Big Murph" Murphy

Mickey Shaughnessy

Al Cruse

Shirley Harmer

Kitty Bishop

James Westerfield

Herb Loftus

Mabel Albertson

Amy Hopkins

Jose Gonzales-Gonzales

Pedro Alonso

Betty Lynn

Molly

Lorne Greene

Clem J. Cummings

Richard Collier

Hotel Desk Clerk

Regis Toomey

Soldier at Fort

Dorothy Crehan

Wife(uncredited)

Joseph Hamilton

Husband(uncredited)