B.T.K. Killer

Gerard Griesbaum

Dennis L. Rader (1974)

Eric Gerleman

Dennis L. Rader (2004)

Victoria Ullmann

Miss Hatch

Shyla Fernandes

Vicki

Danielle Petty

Laci Peterson

Michael Barbour

Jack

Nola Roeper

Paula Rader (2004)

Erin Young

Nancy

Emelle

Dolores

Crystal Nelson

Paula Rader (1974)

Christian Behm

Pastor (2004) / Deputy (1974)

Ricky Love

Pastor (1974)

Yannis Bariamis

Detective

Micah Moses

Dennis

Max Nikoff

Warehouse Worker

Robert Fischer

Mr. Hatch