Hometown Killer

Kaitlyn Black

Tara

Ashley Gallegos

Penny

Will Greenberg

Young Nolan

Sydney Cope

Young Tara

Mary Chris Wall

Detective O'Connell

Michael James Lazar

Kuttler

John Prescott

Charles

Kelly Marcus

Nolan

Chris Devlin

Detective Miller

John Dinan

Intruder

Jensen Higley

Lanie

Joy A. Kennelly

Detective

Christopher Loverro

Police Officer

Emily Rey

Young Penny

Eva Augustina Sinotte

Sherry